Purina Pro Plan and Wellness are beloved pet food brands that have a long history of providing excellent service. Both brands continue to be popular after being in business for nearly a century. It can be difficult to decide which product is best suited to your budget, needs and wants. Which is the best?
For pet owners who want the best, most safe and highest-quality dog food, Wellness is the better choice. Purina Pro plan, on the other hand is more affordable and offers a similar nutritional profile as Wellness.
This article will provide you with all the information that you need to make an informed decision about the best option for your dog’s well-being. To help you make an informed decision about which option is best for you, I will first show you a comparison. Next, I’ll explain each option’s pros & cons so you can make an informed decision about which option is best for you.
Are you just looking for dog food? Click on the links to go to Amazon and see Purina Pro Plan and Wellness.
Purina Pro Plan and Wellness: A General Comparative Study
To help you choose the best option for you, it is important to compare Purina Pro Plan & Wellness in five key categories.
Nutritious valueQuality and safetyPriceCustomer testimonials Variety
Both brands have a nearly century-long history in the industry and have built some of the most loyal and committed customer bases. It’s difficult to determine which brand would best serve your pet’s needs.
Before you read the next sections, prioritize your needs. If your pet has health problems, the best option for you might be to find the least allergen-laden and most nutritious.
However, if your pet’s health is good, spending more money on a product that won’t impact its health may seem like a waste. This is where the price point may be a better criteria to use in your decision-making process.
Let’s move on to the comparison.
Nutritional Value
Before I get into label comparisons, let me remind you that both the federal and state regulations for pet food manufacturing and sales are strict. It’s possible to see the nutritional information for each product and get a good idea of its actual contents.
The most important factor that a pet owner should consider when making a decision about their pet’s health is its nutritional value. Even though pets are able to survive in the most extreme conditions, they thrive when given the right macro- and micronutrients. It is essential that you provide your pet with all the dietary elements it needs in order to maximize its health and longevity.
In terms of their nutritional content, there isn’t much difference between Wellness and Purina Pro Plan. Purina Pro plan products have significantly higher protein content than Wellness, despite having higher fat and fiber contents.
Dogs need protein as a macronutrient. Dogs cannot survive without adequate protein to sustain them throughout their day. It is important to make sure that the protein you choose for your dog’s food is not only high quality but also concentrated.
Although exact protein content can vary between products, Purina’s Pro Plan is the best when it comes to protein supply. Some of their products can even compete with more expensive options because of their extraordinary protein content.
Purina Pro Plan is the best choice if you want to give your pet more protein. But that’s not the end of Purina Pro Plan’s nutritional superiority.
Protein is not the only element that’s important for your pet’s health and well-being. Your dog’s longevity and health will depend on how well your dog eats. The undisputed advantage on all of these fronts is wellness.
Specific ratios may vary widely from one product to the next. However, Wellness is the clear winner when it comes fat content.
You’ll need to ensure your pet has enough fats. Fats is an essential macronutrient that they must have.
Fibers, on the other hand are great for your pet’s intestinal tract. The fiber content of all these products is approximately the same. It shouldn’t affect your decision.
Let’s not forget micronutrients. Wellness is the best because it contains many vitamins and minerals that will help your pet live a long and healthy life.
Even though the brands are similar nutrition-wise, I think Wellness has a better profile. Purina Pro Plan products have significantly higher protein content, but their Wellness counterparts contain more fat and micronutrients.
Quality and Safety
The health-inducing situation is not just about the nutritional value. A product may appear to have high levels of protein, fat and fiber, but the label doesn’t tell you how quality these elements are. This is unfortunate as quality is often more important than the ratios.
Not all proteins are created equal. Chicken and lamb will be easier for dogs to digest than beef. You shouldn’t be concerned if the product has meat by-products not commonly consumed by humans. Your pet’s blood and other organs can be a great source of iron and protein.
We’ve now established the importance and benefits of qualitative macronutrients. Now it’s time for us to dive into the details.
Wellness is the better brand in terms of quality, even though their products contain some controversial ingredients such as colors, garlic powder, pea protein, and color. While Wellness has more organic ingredients than Purina Pro plan, it is well-known for using corn- and grain-based fillers to overpower its high-quality protein sources.
Purina Pro Plan products also contain ingredients that could be harmful to animals’ health such as corn oil and animal fats preserved with citric acid. These elements are not part of Wellness.
Important to remember that Purina Pro Plan was recalled multiple times. The most recent recall occurred in 2021 after Purina Pro Plan claimed that certain cans of wet foods contained plastic traces. You can read more about the brand’s history of recalls here.
Purina Pro Plan, despite its unsavory recall history as well as some questionable ingredients is still a top-quality option on the market. Wellness, despite having a more limited selection of ingredients, has been recalled multiple times.
The most recent instance was recorded in March 2017. This is when some people claimed that there was an excess of beef thyroid hormone within their products. This article provides more information about Wellness’ recall history.
Price
You might conclude that Wellness is slightly ahead of its rival in terms nutritional value, ingredient quality, safety, and other aspects.
However, there is a crucial question that we have yet to answer: Are the nutritional, safety and quality differences substantial enough to explain the price difference between their products?
In terms of price, Wellness is definitely more expensive than Purina Pro Plan. All Wellness products are more costly than their Purina Pro Plan equivalents.
Sometimes, the price per calorie for Purina Pro Plan items can be half that of its rivals. Because of differences in volume, weight and moisture, price per calorie is often the best way to distinguish between brands.
Purina Pro plan is the clear winner if you are on a tight budget. In general, the small price difference doesn’t justify the quality difference, especially if you are trying to save.
The FDA recommends Purina Pro Plan as a brand. It is safe to assume that the ingredients are not a health risk for most pets, provided they do not have any pre-existing conditions or other risk factors.
As long as your pet’s health is good, Purina Pro Plan offers a greater overall value than its price. If your pet is sensitive to certain colors, additives or allergens, you might want to consider Wellness.
Customer Testimonials
Customer testimonials are the best way to base your decision. It doesn’t matter how high quality and healthy a product may appear on paper. However, not all products work well with all pets. It is important to learn from other owners in order to make an informed decision.
In order to help you, I searched several forums Yi that deal with pets such as PetCoach and Golden Retriever ForumYi for testimonials that could give you an idea of which brand might be best for you.
Customers are overwhelmingly positive about the Purina Pro Plan for young puppies. They claim that the higher-end brands such as Wellness can sometimes be too much for pets’ fragile and growing bodies to handle. Some micro- and macronutrients can cause rapid weight gain and abnormal joint development, which could lead to an increase in arthritis risk.
Some owners feel that Purina Pro Plan’s inefficient and costly cost-cutting methods mean excessive additives are just a way to hide the low quality of their ingredients. They feel that the additional investment is worthwhile as you will be more sure of what food your pet is eating.
Others point out that Wellness attaches the “Organic” label to many of its products and ingredients. This means that the brand’s manufacturing process is more tightly controlled and the quality of the final product. They claim that this extra investment is worth it as tighter manufacturing regulations often lead to safer and better-quality products.
You’ll get different answers depending on who you ask about which brand provides a greater overall value. Because each owner’s experience will be different, it is because of their unique circumstances.
Sometimes, research is not enough. You can have the best quality meats, but your pet may not like them.
As much as you may want to rely solely on research, it is a smart idea to take into account your dog’s nutritional requirements and preferences. You want your dog to enjoy the food you choose and get all of its micro and macronutrients.
Products
When choosing a brand to buy from, owners who have very picky dogs will need to consider the product range. Purina Pro Plan and Wellness have a wide variety of products to suit pets of all ages and medical conditions. You’ll find something that will please even the pickiest eaters.
Wellness is slightly ahead of the pack on this one. Wellness offers a greater variety of traditional dry and wet dog food as well as tasty, healthy, and fun treats.
Purina Pro Plan, on the other hand, focuses more heavily on traditional dry and/or wet food and has not yet produced treats. If you want to provide all your pet’s nutrition needs with one brand, Wellness is the best choice.
Pros and cons of Purina Pro Plan
class=”size-large aligncenter” src=”https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41BMzZ8skKL._SL500_.jpg” alt=”Purina Pro Plan High Protein Dog Food With Probiotics for Dogs, Shredded Blend Chicken & Rice Formula – 35 lb. Bag” title=”Purina PRO Plan High Protein Dog Food with Probiotics For Dogs, Shredded Chicken & Rice Formula- 35 lb. Bag”>
You might be able to identify the best company for your pet and family by comparing their nutritional value, safety, quality, price, customer reviews, and product range.
But just because one brand is better than the other does not mean its products are worth your long-term investment. A pros and cons analysis is essential when creating a pet’s diet plan.
Pros
Pet owners have loved Purina Pro Plan products for nearly a century. There are many reasons why.
The brand is a great value for the price. Purina Pro plan is a brand that offers a unique nutritional profile, which is hard to find in other brands within the same price range.
Their many product options are able to cater to all health needs and preferences. Their “Sensitive Stomach”, a line that treats digestive problems in pets, has proved to be a huge hit with owners.
Their dry and wet foods are a great option for pet owners looking for the right nutrition for their elderly or young pets. Purina ProPlan is a great choice for dogs with sensitive stomachs.
Their products are also high in protein. Purina Pro plan, for example, is a more expensive brand than Wellness, but provides a higher protein intake in the same amount of food.
Their products may be less quality than those of more expensive brands. Comparing Purina Pro Plan to other manufacturers in the same price range will show that they sell better quality products with fewer filler ingredients.
Cons
These pros do not change the fact there are safer and better-quality alternatives. Your pet may be more happy consuming a higher-end option if budget is not an issue.
Although pets may have evolved to survive extreme conditions, providing their owners with the right nutrition profile will help them live longer and be healthier. This is what every owner wants. It might be worth it to invest in the best products on the market.
Purina Pro Plan products can contain potentially harmful ingredients, such as colorings and animal fat preserved with acid. They are not recommended for pets.
Purina Pro Plan may not be the right choice for dogs with food allergies or sensitivities. They contain soy and other allergens that could be harmful to your pet’s health.
Important to remember that recalls of products by the brand have occurred several times over their long history because of quality control issues.
Finally, Purina Pro Plan still uses a lot of grain in their recipes, even though they sell some of the best protein-rich products available. This is a problem for your pet’s longevity and health.
The Pros and Cons of Wellness
class=”size-large aligncenter” src=”https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/51eFf+B4GjL._SL500_.jpg” alt=”Wellness Natural Pet Food Complete Health Natural Dry Large Breed Dog Food, Chicken & Rice, 30-Pound Bag” title=”Wellness Natural Pet Food Complete Health Natural Dry Large Breed Dog Food, Chicken & Rice, 30-Pound Bag”>
You might have seen in previous sections that Wellness is a brand that belongs to the top-end of the industry.
This analysis will help you weigh the pros and cons of this brand’s food and treats. You’ll be able to determine if the product’s quality and features are worth the high price.
These are the pros and con’s of this well-known brand.
Pros
Because of its high-quality pet food and treats, Wellness has enjoyed a loyal customer base for almost a century. Look at the ingredient list of their products. The first item will be a meat type (usually chicken) that makes up more than 70% of the entire can or package. This is a sign that the product is quality, as any pet food expert or vet will tell you.
They offer high-quality meats in impressive amounts. There is very little room for grains or fillers, which can cause health problems in pets.
Wellness sells a variety of treats and foods that are suitable for pets of all ages and breeds. Their products are high in essential micronutrients and healthy fats that can help improve the well-being of your dog.
Cons
The biggest problem with Wellness is its high cost. Because of their high price, the brand’s products can be difficult to access. Their protein content is also a little low considering the investment that you will be making if they are your long-term customers.
Their meat-based products are excellent, but they retain too much water. You’ll notice a significant shrinkage in the size of the products when you cook them.
Wellness, like Purina Pro plan, has a long history recalls. Wellness is a similar product, so brands selling at the same price point face less legal problems.
Last Thoughts
You need to consider several important criteria when choosing the right dog food brand. These include safety, nutritional value, price, customer testimonials, product variety, and quality. The Purina Pro Plan and Wellness are superior in quality if we compare them head-to-head. The latter, on the other hand is a better choice for people with limited budgets.
Each brand has its own pros and cons. You should consider all aspects when choosing the best alternative to get the highest return.
Similar ArticlesPurina PRO Plan vs. FROMM: Which Dog Food is Better?
